The purpose of United Nations Security Council practice: Contesting competence claims in the normative context created by the Responsibility to Protect
نویسندگان
چکیده
Practice theory provides important insights into the workings of the Security Council. The contribution is currently limited, however, by the conjecture that practice theory operates on 'a different analytical plane' to norm/normative theory. Building on existing critiques, we argue that analysing practices separately from normative positions risks misappropriating competence and reifying practice that is not fit for purpose. This risk is realized in Adler-Nissen and Pouliot's practice-based account of the Libya crisis. By returning the normative context created by the Responsibility to Protect to the analytical foreground, and by drawing on a pragmatic conception of 'ethical competence', we find that pre-reflexive practices uncritically accepted as markers of competence - for example, 'penholding' - can contribute to the Council's failure to act collectively in the face of mass atrocity. Drawing on extensive interview material, we offer an alternative account of the Libya intervention, finding that the practices of the permanent three (France, the UK and the US) did not cultivate the kind of collective consciousness that is required to implement the Responsibility to Protect. This is further illustrated by an account of the Security Council's failure in Syria, where the permanent three's insistence on regime change instrumentalized the Council at the expense of Responsibility to Protect-appropriate practice. This changed when elected members became 'penholders'. Practice theory can facilitate learning processes that help the Council meet its responsibilities, but only through an approach that combines its insights with those of norm/normative theory.
منابع مشابه
Reasons behind the Failure of Right to Peace in Today’s World
The right to peace and global security are considered as critical rights and necessities for human life, the realization of which requires support of the global society. Initially, the establishment of the United Nations made people believe that they are achieving this significant matter, and a major part of problems caused by disagreements and growing wars are being solved. Unfortunately, this...
متن کاملContext-Based Integrative Educational Technique in Profession-Oriented Foreign Language Teaching (Academic Model United Nations)
The aim of the article is to examine the Academic Model United Nations (Model UN) as a context-based integrative educational technique in profession-oriented foreign language teaching (FLT); to point out the context-based integrative nature of profession-oriented language learning and highlight the importance of using product-based educational techniques in FLT for developing students’ future p...
متن کاملواکاوی قانونی بودن و مشروعیت تحریم های یکجانبه اقتصادی تحت حقوق بین الملل
Abstract Sanctions have always been imposed to achieve certain goals. Security Council which is responsible to maintain international peace and security, can impose sanctions under article 41 of the U.N Charter to implement its decisions. On the other side, states also unilaterally impose sanctions against others to achieve their national goals and interests. In this context, sanctions are...
متن کاملFAILURE TO PROTECT: Study of the UN Security Council and The Responsibility to Protect in regard to the Syrian civil war
متن کامل
The Accountability Levels of Saudi Arabia towards United Nations Mechanisms (2009-2016)
The Human Rights Council (HRC) is one of the sub-bodies of the UN General Assembly, whose duty is to point out human rights violation cases and promote the accountability of states in this regard. The UPR is the most important monitoring tools of the HRC with the aim of monitoring, promotion and protection of human rights in all states and based on dialogue and cooperation, and is based on reli...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره 23 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2017